The Human Side of Community ROI: Stories That Numbers Can’t Measure

In the world of community building, measuring success has often been about numbers. Engagement rates, growth metrics, and activity levels are the traditional metrics that many organizations rely on to gauge the impact of their communities. But what about the intangible benefits that numbers alone can’t capture? The sense of belonging, personal transformation, and human connection are all key elements of community ROI that deserve attention. This post explores the human side of community ROI, focusing on the stories and experiences of community members — the things that numbers simply can’t measure.

Defining Community ROI Beyond Numbers

The importance of tracking community ROI cannot be overstated. Metrics such as user growth, event attendance, and engagement rates are helpful in understanding the reach and activity of a community. However, they often fail to show the true impact of a community on an individual level.

In previous blog posts, Talkbase explores both qualitative and quantitative metrics to evaluate community impact. As seen in Qualitative vs. Quantitative Community Metrics, qualitative metrics such as personal stories, testimonials, and member feedback offer deeper insight into how a community makes its members feel, what they’ve learned, and how they’ve grown. This is the side of community ROI that is often overlooked but is just as important as the numbers.

Community leaders need to remember that human connections, the shared experiences and relationships that are fostered within a community,  are not just “nice to have” but are central to its long-term success. These human experiences shape the culture of a community and can drive further engagement, trust, and loyalty.

The Power of Personal Stories

Consider this: a community member who, upon joining, felt isolated and uncertain. Through active participation and forming meaningful relationships within the group, they experienced increased self-worth and reduced stress levels. This transformation is supported by research indicating that having a best friend present during negative experiences can decrease cortisol levels and enhance feelings of self-worth.

These narratives highlight the profound impact of social connections on individual health. Chronic loneliness has been linked to a 50% increase in mortality risk, comparable to the risks associated with smoking. Such statistics underscore the importance of fostering genuine relationships within communities.

One of the most impactful aspects of community is the sense of belonging it creates. As I shared in Embracing True Inclusion: Why Belonging Matters, cultivating an environment where people feel they truly belong allows for deeper engagement and connection. These personal stories highlight that belonging is often the cornerstone of real transformation within communities.

Why These Stories Matter

The significance of these personal stories extends beyond individual well-being; they also influence organizational outcomes. Employees who feel a sense of purpose and belonging are more satisfied, even in roles with relatively low wages. A recent survey highlighted that structural factors like job security, supportive management, and engaging roles significantly contribute to employee satisfaction, leading to better talent retention and productivity.

If we review my article, The Business Case for Community, we see that the power of community isn’t just about how many people are involved but how deeply they are involved. Members who feel connected are more likely to stay engaged, contribute, and even champion the community outside its walls. They create a ripple effect that goes beyond just the immediate group, helping to recruit new members and build long-term sustainability.

When organizations track the human side of community ROI, they can see how stories of connection, empowerment, and personal growth can translate into increased retention, stronger advocacy, and more authentic engagement. These intangible results are often overlooked in traditional ROI metrics, but they are just as important in understanding a community's impact.

Measuring What Matters: Going Beyond the Numbers

So, how can organizations begin to measure the human side of community ROI? It’s all about creating spaces for members to share their stories. While hard metrics will always be valuable, it's important to also prioritize feedback from members that highlights their emotional and personal experiences within the community.

Consider implementing strategies such as:

• Surveys and polls to gather qualitative feedback
• One-on-one interviews with community members to dive deeper into their experiences
• Open forums or storytelling sessions that allow members to share their journeys with others

This data doesn’t have to replace quantitative metrics, instead, it complements them. Together, they offer a richer, fuller picture of a community’s success.

Final Thoughts

At the end of the day, community ROI is about far more than just the numbers. It’s about the connections that are made, the stories that are shared, and the lives that are transformed. As we continue to build and nurture communities, we must recognize and value both sides of the equation, the numbers and the human stories.

Organizations that embrace this holistic view of community ROI will see not only growth in membership but also a deeper, more engaged community that can withstand the test of time. After all, the most meaningful returns often can’t be quantified, they can only be felt.

‍

Sources:
ft.com: Healthcare salaries fail to keep up with workers’ commitment

Wikipedia: Social connection

Well-being contributing factors

‍